Saturday, June 12, 2010

Walgreen's States Equal Protection Claim

San Francisco prohibits pharmacies such as Walgreen's from selling cigarettes, but not grocery stores or big box stores even if they contain licensed pharmacies. Walgreen's sued contending that this distinction lacked a rational basis. The Superior Court agreed, but the Court of Appeal held that Walgreen's could state a cause of action (here). The court held that the City's rationale for the ordinance--that cigarettes should not be sold in retail establishments such as pharmacies that are identified in the public mind with health--did not apply to chain stores like Walgreen's, that typically sell products that are largely indistinguishable from those sold in grocery stores. The court also held that the city could not defend its disparate treatment of pharmacies and grocery stores by the need to keep supermarkets in San Francisco.

I think this case has a shot at Supreme Court review. The court's opinion is certainly less deferential to the city that courts usually are in evaluating legislation under the rational basis test.

13 comments:

林奕廷 said...

被人揭下面具是一種失敗,自己揭下面具卻是種勝利。..................................................................

Anonymous said...

幸福不是一切,人還有責任。............................................................

Anonymous said...

It takes all kinds to make a world.............................................................

Anonymous said...

感謝您費心的分享您的生活!讓我也感同身受!..................................................................

Anonymous said...

Words are not living in dictionary. Words are living in mind.............................................................

Anonymous said...

Better be the head of a dog than the tail of a lion...................................................................

Anonymous said...

河水永遠是相同的,可是每一剎那又都是新的。..................................................

Anonymous said...

first catch your hare, then cook him. ..................................................

Anonymous said...

你不能決定生命的長度,但你可以控制它的寬度..................................................................

Anonymous said...

生命中最美麗的報償之一便是幫助他人的同時,也幫助了自己。.......................................................

Anonymous said...

人生中最好的禮物就是屬於自己的一部份............................................................

Anonymous said...

Judge not a book by its cover.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Anonymous said...

一個人的價值,應該看他貢獻了什麼,而不是他取得了什麼....................................................